Barney rejects the interpretation that the function argument is not a real argument but rather a list of examples (as argued by Aristotle scholars Broadie and Irwin). Why?

Question

Barney rejects the interpretation that the function argument is not a real argument but rather a list of examples (as argued by Aristotle scholars Broadie and Irwin).  Why?

Answer

It is incompatible with the text passages that follow after the function argument.

Answer

It was refuted by Kraut's more recent interpretation.

Answer

It is not ambitious enough, plus some of the listed items seem bad examples.

Answer

It rests on a mistaken translation of the Greek text.

Answer

It does not fit with the historical context of a Greek polis.

Crowdly

Barney rejects the interpretation that the function argument is not a real argum...

Want instant access to all verified answers on moodle.concordia.ca?